Case: 2012-CA-000083    Show/Hide Menu
  
 Appellant:WILLIAMMATTINGLY
 vs 
 Appellee:DAISYMITCHELL, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF (OF LATONIA MITCHELL AND BARBARA A. COWAN)
 
 Opinion:2012-CA-000083 (PDF)
 

Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
 Case #:2012-CA-000083
 Case Type:CI Direct appeal - Civil
 Document Type:Matter of Right Appeal (MR)
 Document Type:History (H)
 Last Main Event:FINALITY (FL)
 Presiding Judge:HON . KELLY THOMPSON JR
 Associate Judge:HON. SARA W. COMBS
 Associate Judge:HON. JANET L. STUMBO
 

StepSheet   Case Information   Litigants Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
Step #DateDescriptionMemo
112/14/2011CIRCUIT COURT JUDGMENT 
201/09/2012NOTICE OF APPEAL - REGULAR CIVIL$160.00 FILING FEE PAID.
301/27/2012PREHEARING STATEMENT 
402/22/2012READY - PREHEARING 
502/22/2012ASSIGNMENT - PRE-HEARING 
603/01/2012PRE-HEARING DENIED 
703/01/2012ORDER ENTERED TO STARTAPPELLANT FILED DESIGNATION OF EVIDIENCE BYWILIAM MATTINGLY
903/26/2012NOTIF. OF CERTIFICATION - REGULAR CIVIL 
1007/02/2012APPEAL PERFECTED 
1107/02/2012SUBSTANTIVE MOTIONJOINT MOTION /TREATED AS APPELLANT/CROSS-APPELLEE MOTION TO DISMISS BARBARA A. COWAN AS A PARTY TO THE APPEAL. ### D/13
1207/11/2012APPELLEE BRIEF FILEDAPPELLEE/CROSS APPELLANT BRIEF FILED BY KEVIN C. BURKE
1307/13/2012MOTIONS SCHEDULED FOR FOLLOWING STEPS. 
1408/09/2012ORDER GRANTING SUBSTANTIVE MOTIONORDER - GRANTING JOINT MOTION /TREATED AS APPELLANT/CROSS-APPELLEE MOTION TO DISMISS BARBARA A. COWAN AS A PARTY TO THE APPEAL.
1508/30/2012APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEFAPPELLANT/CROSS APPELLEE FILED BY GARY SIEMENS
1609/17/2012RECORD REQUEST FROM CIRCUIT COURT CLRKREQUEST SCANNED AND E-MAILED TO JEFFERSON C.C. ### UPDATED PER RR REPORT - KS 10/8/12
1710/17/2012RECORD FILEDAS FILED IN 2012-CA-121 3 VOLUMES RECORD 1 BROWN FOLDER OF MISC. ###RECORD FILED ON N-6
1810/19/2012SUBMISSION 
1912/18/2012APPEAL ASSIGNED ON THE MERITSASSIGNED MONTH: 03/2013 PRESIDING JUDGE: THOMPSON, HON. KELLY PANEL: 2 NOTE:
2001/09/2013NON ORAL NOTICE 
2205/10/2013ORDER ON COURT'S OWN MOTIONNOTICE OF SUBSTITUTION - JUSTICE MICHELLE KELLER, AN ASSOCIATE JUDGE IN CASE NO. 2012-CA-000083 AND CASE NO. 2012-CA-000121, HAS BEEN APPOINTED TO THE KENTUCKY SUPREME COURT. BECAUSE JUSTICE KELLER CANNOT SIT ON THE CASE, JUDGE SARA COMBS HAS BEENSUBSTITUTED AS ASSOCIATE JUDGE. JUDGE KELLY THOMPSON, PRESIDING JUDGE, JUDGE SARA COMBS AND JUDGE JANET STUMBO.
2306/21/2013OPINION - AFFIRMINGOPINION AFFIRMING THOMPSON COMBS (CONCURS) AND STUMBO (CONCURS) TO BE PUBLISHED 14 PAGES
2406/28/2013RECORD RETURNED FROM JUDGE'S CHAMBERS.JUDGE THOMPSON RETURNED 1 BROWN CASE WALLET AND 1 BOX OF RECORD ON SHELF #26 ON 6/28/13.
2704/17/2014PUBLICATION LETTER 
2804/17/2014FINALITYRETURNED 3 VOLUMES RECORD, 1 FOLDER ATTACHMENTS TO THE JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT BY UPS. UPS TRACKING # 1Z E40 237 03 4296 3007 6/17/14- RECEIVED COPY OF RECEIPT FROM THE JEFFERSON CIRCUIT COURT NOT DATED.
 

Litigant Information   Case Information   StepSheet Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
DescriptionPrimary(Y/N)NameSeq #
AppellantYWILLIAMMATTINGLY 1
AppelleeYDAISYMITCHELL, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF OF LATONIA MITCHELL AND BARBARA A. COWAN2
 

Attorney Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Circuit Appeals
 
Attorney(s)Attorney's AddressParty NameParty Type
GARY E SIEMENS BENSON, RISCH & LANGE, PLLC, SUITE 2150, ONE RIVERFRONT PLAZA, LOUISVILLE, KY 40202 WILLIAMMATTINGLY Appellant
GARY E SIEMENS BENSON, RISCH & LANGE, PLLC, SUITE 2150, ONE RIVERFRONT PLAZA, LOUISVILLE, KY 40202 DAISYMITCHELL, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF OF LATONIA MITCHELL AND BARBARA A. COWAN Appellee
JOHN A. DECAMILLIS DECAMILLIS & SMITH, 150 SOUTH THIRD STREET, LOUISVILLE, KY 40202 DAISYMITCHELL, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF OF LATONIA MITCHELL AND BARBARA A. COWAN Appellee
TIMOTHY D LANGE BENSON, BYRNE, & RISCH, LLP, ONE RIVERFRONT PLAZA, 401 W. MAIN STREET, SUITE 2150, LOUISVILLE, KY 40202 WILLIAMMATTINGLY Appellant
ROBERT DENTON MATTINGLY DECAMILLIS & SMITH, PLLC, 150 SOUTH THIRD STREET, LOUISVILLE, KY 40202 DAISYMITCHELL, AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF OF LATONIA MITCHELL AND BARBARA A. COWAN Appellee
 

Circuit Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Appeals
 
CountyCase #Judgement DateJudge Name
JEFFERSON(056)(Case #: 08-CI-007808 ) (Court:1) (Division:Circuit Court )12/14/2011WILLETT, BARRY
 

Associated Appeals Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Circuit
 
Cases
2012-CA-000121