Case: 2012-CA-000660    Show/Hide Menu
  
 Appellant:BONITABEAUMONT
 vs 
 Appellee:MULUKENZERU
 
 Opinion:2012-CA-000660 (PDF)
 

Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
 Case #:2012-CA-000660
 Case Type:CI Direct appeal - Civil
 Document Type:Matter of Right Appeal (MR)
 Document Type:History (H)
 Last Main Event:FINALITY (FL)
 Presiding Judge:HON . JOY A. KRAMER
 Associate Judge:HON. SARA W. COMBS
 Associate Judge:HON. JEFF S. TAYLOR
 

StepSheet   Case Information   Litigants Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
Step #DateDescriptionMemo
104/02/2012CIRCUIT COURT JUDGMENT 
204/06/2012NOTICE OF APPEAL - REGULAR CIVIL$160.00 FILING FEE PAID.
304/26/2012PREHEARING STATEMENT 
505/08/2012READY - PREHEARING 
605/08/2012ASSIGNMENT - PRE-HEARING 
705/24/2012PRE-HEARING GRANTED 
805/24/2012PREHEARING CONF SCHED DATE TIME LOCATIONJUNE 26, 2012 1:00 PM LOUISVILLE ATTY (P.S.)
907/26/2012PREHEARING CONF RESULT (NO SETTLEMENT) 
1007/26/2012ORDER ENTERED TO START 
1108/22/2012NOTIF. OF CERTIFICATION - REGULAR CIVIL 
1209/26/2012APPEAL PERFECTED 
1311/26/2012APPELLEE BRIEF FILEDAPPELLEE BRIEF FILED BY W. DOUGLAS KEMPER **PER COURT ORDER ENTERED 12/21/12, STRIKE THE APPELLEE BRIEF FILED NOV. 26, 2012 AND FILE THE TENDERED CORRECTED APPELLEE BRIEF THIS DATE.*** CALLED COUNSEL RECYCLED STRICKEN BRIEFS ***
1411/29/2012PROCEDURAL MOTIONAPPELLEE'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE A CORRECTED APPELLEE BRIEF. ( TENDERED CORRECTED APPELLEE BRIEF) ### D/12
1512/10/2012APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEFAPPELLANT, BY COUNSEL, FILED REPLY BRIEF.
1612/12/2012MOTIONS SCHEDULED FOR FOLLOWING STEPS. 
1812/21/2012ORDER GRANTING PROCEDURAL MOTIONORDER - APPELLEE'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE A CORRECTED APPELLEE BRIEF, IS HEREBY GRANTED. THE CLERK OF THIS COURT IS DIRECTED TO STRIKE THE APPELLEE BRIEF FILED NOV. 26, 2012 AND FILE THE TENDERED CORRECTED APPELLEE BRIEF THIS DATE.
1912/21/2012APPELLEE BRIEF FILEDPER COURT ORDER APPELLEE'S CORRECTED BRIEF FILED
2012/21/2012RECORD REQUEST FROM CIRCUIT COURT CLRK 
2101/08/2013RECORD FILED3 VOLUMES OF RECORD
2201/11/2013SUBMISSION 
2403/07/2013APPEAL ASSIGNED ON THE MERITSASSIGNED MONTH: 06/2013 PRESIDING JUDGE: MOORE, HON. JOY A. PANEL: 3 NOTE:
2503/22/2013NON ORAL NOTICE 
2606/28/2013OPINION - AFFIRMINGOPINION AFFIRMING MOORE TAYLOR (CONCURS) AND COMBS (DISSENTS AND FILES SEPARATE OPINION) NOT TO BE PUBLISHED 7 PAGES
2807/25/2013DISC. REVIEW FILED KY SUPREME COURTMOTION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW FILED IN SUPREME COURT. 2013-SC-489-D
2908/05/2013RECORD RETURNED FROM JUDGE'S CHAMBERS.JUDGE MOORE RETURNED 1 BROWN CASE WALLET ON 8/5/13.
3004/09/2014DISC. REVIEW GRANTED BY SUPREME CT.ORDER GRANTING DISCRETIONARY REVIEW IN SUPREME COURT. 2013-SC-489-D
3204/02/2015SUPREME COURT OPINIONKENTUCKY SUPREME COURT OPINION REVERSING AND REMANDING
3406/15/2015FINALITY 
 

Litigant Information   Case Information   StepSheet Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
DescriptionPrimary(Y/N)NameSeq #
AppellantYBONITABEAUMONT 1
AppelleeYMULUKENZERU 2
 

Attorney Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Circuit Appeals
 
Attorney(s)Attorney's AddressParty NameParty Type
EDWARD C. AIRHART AIRHART & ASSOCIATES, 440 SOUTH SEVENTH STREET, SUITE 200, LOUISVILLE, KY 40203 BONITABEAUMONT Appellant
WILLIAM D KEMPER GWIN STEINMETZ MILLER & BAIRD PLLC, 401 W. MAIN STREET, SUITE 1000, LOUISVILLE, KY 40202 MULUKENZERU Appellee
 

Circuit Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Appeals
 
CountyCase #Judgement DateJudge Name
JEFFERSON(056)(Case #: 11-CI-006183 ) (Court:1) (Division:Circuit Court )04/02/2012WILLETT, BARRY
 

Associated Appeals Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Circuit
None