Case: 2013-CA-000147    Show/Hide Menu
  
 Appellant:MOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY
 vs 
 Appellee:GYPSIETHACKER
 
 Opinion:2013-CA-000147 (PDF)
 

Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
 Case #:2013-CA-000147
 Case Type:CI Direct appeal - Civil
 Document Type:Matter of Right Appeal (MR)
 Document Type:History (H)
 Last Main Event:FINALITY (FL)
 Presiding Judge:HON . SARA W. COMBS
 Associate Judge:HON. DONNA L. DIXON
 Associate Judge:HON. JAMES H. LAMBERT
 

StepSheet   Case Information   Litigants Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
Step #DateDescriptionMemo
112/21/2012CIRCUIT COURT JUDGMENTALSO APPEALING: 1/12/11 8/10/11 10/19/11
201/18/2013NOTICE OF APPEAL - REGULAR CIVIL$185.00 FILING FEE PAID.
302/06/2013PREHEARING STATEMENT 
402/19/2013SUPPLEMENTAL PRE-HEARING STATEMENT 
502/19/2013PROCEDURAL MOTIONMOTION FOR LEAVE FOR JIM G. VANOVER TO BE NOTED AS CO-COUNSEL FOR APPELLEE. ### D/5
703/05/2013MOTIONS SCHEDULED FOR FOLLOWING STEPS. 
803/08/2013ORDER GRANTING PROCEDURAL MOTIONORDER - THE MOTION BY JIM G. HANOVER TO BE ENTERED AS CO-COUNSEL FOR APPELLEE GYPSIE THACKER HAS BEEN GRANTED.
903/08/2013READY - PREHEARING 
1003/08/2013ASSIGNMENT - PRE-HEARING 
1103/12/2013PRE-HEARING DENIED 
1203/12/2013ORDER ENTERED TO START 
1303/20/2013PROCEDURAL MOTIONAPPELLANT'S MOTION TO FILE AMENDED PREHEARING STATEMENT. ( TENDERED AMENDED PREHEARING STATEMENT) ### D/2
1404/01/2013RESPONSE TO MOTIONAPPELLEE GYPSIE THACKER RESPONSE TO APPELLANT'S MOTION TO FILE AMENDED PREHEARING STATEMENT.
1504/02/2013MOTIONS SCHEDULED FOR FOLLOWING STEPS. 
1704/09/2013NOTIF. OF CERTIFICATION - REGULAR CIVIL6/18/13 - SPOKE W/MARLENE, PIKE C.C. TO CLARIFY THE NOTICE OF CERTIFICATIONS RECEIVED AS FOLLOWS: 4/9/13 ORIGINAL NOTICE OF CERTIFICATION (RECEIVED 4/11/13) LISTED 1736 PAGES OF RECORD (INCORRECT # OF PAGES). 4/15/13 AMENDED NOTICE OF CERTIFICATION (RECEIVED 4/18/13) CORRECTED PAGES TO 1652 PAGES, BUT LISTED THE DATE AS 4/15/13, INSTEAD OF 4/9/13. 4/9/13 AMENDED NOTICE OF CERTIFICATION (RECEIVED BY FAX 4/22/13) CORRECTED THE CERTICATION DATE AS 4/9/13, INSTEAD OF 4/15/13. KEEPING THE PAGES AS 1652 PAGES. ### KS 6/18/13
1804/23/2013ORDER GRANTING PROCEDURAL MOTIONORDER - APPELLANT/CROSS-APPELLEE'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN AMENDED PREHEARING STATEMENT IN APPEAL NO. 2013-CA-000147-MR IS GRANTED. THE TENDERED AMENDED PREHEARING STATEMENT SHALL BE FILED THE DATE OF ENTRY OF THIS ORDER.
1904/23/2013PREHEARING STATEMENTAMENDED PREHEARING STATEMENT FILED PURSUANT TO COURT ORDER.
2005/24/2013PROCEDURAL MOTIONAPPELLANT/CROSS-APPELLEE MOTION TO EXCEED THE PAGE LIMITATION. ### D/7
2106/07/2013MOTIONS SCHEDULED FOR FOLLOWING STEPS. 
2206/10/2013TENDERED DOCUMENTAPPELLANT BRIEF WAS RECEIVED 06/10/13 AND TENDERED. MOTION SCHEDULED. ###S/A AWARE AND HOLDING ON CC DESK
2306/13/2013APPELLEE'S MOTION TO DISMISSAPPELLEE/CROSS-APPELLANT MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL NO. 2013-CA-147. ### D/25 SCAN TO W.D.
2406/18/2013RESPONSE TO MOTIONAPPELLANT'S RESPONSE TO APPELLEE/CROSS-APPELLANT MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL NO. 2013-CA-147.
2506/25/2013MOTIONS SCHEDULED FOR FOLLOWING STEPS. 
2911/19/2013ORDER DENYING APPELLEE MOTION TO DISMISSORDER - DENYING APPELLEE/CROSS-APPELLANT MOTION TO DISMISS APPEAL NO. 2013-CA-147.
3011/19/2013ORDER DENYING PROCEDURAL MOTIONORDER - DENYING APPELLANT/CROSS-APPELLEE MOTION TO EXCEED THE PAGE LIMITATION.
3111/19/2013DEFICIENCY ORDER - RETURN OF DEFICIENT PLEADING ON COURT'S OWN MOTIONORDER - RETAINING TENDERED APPELLANT BRIEF, APPELLANT SHALL HAVE 15 DAYS TO CORRECT DEFICIENCIES THAT ARE SPELLED OUT IN THE ORDER. APPELLANTS MAY FILE A 30 PAGE BRIEF IN COMPLIANCE WITH CR 76.12(4). ###D-5 CC
3212/02/2013APPEAL PERFECTED 
3301/28/2014APPELLEE BRIEF FILEDAPPELLEE BRIEF WAS FILED BY JIM G. VANOVER
3402/11/2014APPELLANT'S REPLY BRIEFAPPELLANT, BY COUNSEL, FILED REPLY BRIEF.
3502/12/2014RECORD REQUEST FROM CIRCUIT COURT CLRK 
3602/24/2014RECORD FILED8 VOLUMES DEPOSITION 12 VOLUMES RECORD 1 EXHIBIT (PICTURE) 1 ANSWER TO INTERROGATORIES 1 EXHIBIT DEPO RECORD FILED ON N-4 RECEIVED THE FOLLOWING ADDITIONAL RECORDS 5/12/14 1 ENVELOPE MISC. 1 ENVELOPE SEALED 6 ENVELOPES EXHIBITS 19 DEPOSITIONS 7 MEMORANDOMS / REPLIES 9 MOTION'S / REPLIES 3 INTERROGATORIES 1 PETITION WRIT OF MANDAMUS 1 PRETRIAL COMPLIANCE 11 CD'S PACKED IN 3 BOXES
3702/21/2014SUBMISSION 
3802/27/2014APPEAL ASSIGNED ON THE MERITSASSIGNED MONTH: 05/2014 PRESIDING JUDGE: COMBS, HON. SARA W. PANEL: 3 NOTE:
3903/28/2014NON ORAL NOTICE 
4208/01/2014OPINION - REVERSING & REMANDING**WITHDRAWN ON 2/6/15** OPINION REVERSING AND REMANDING DIXON COMBS (CONCURS) AND CAPERTON (DISSENTS AND FILES SEPARATE OPINION) NOT TO BE PUBLISHED 20 PAGES [REINSERTED STEP-PAB-4/2/15]
4308/14/2014PETITION FOR REHEARINGAPPELLANT, BY COUNSEL, FILED PETITION FOR REHEARING, ON BEHALF OF MOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY. $150 FILING FEE PAID (#6712). ###D-4 (DP) [REINSERTED STEP-PAB-4/2/15]
4408/19/2014PETITION FOR REHEARINGAPPELLEE, BY COUNSEL, FILED PETITION FOR REHEARING ON BEHALF OF GYPSIE THACKER, ET AL. $150.00 FILING FEE PAID (#14961) ###D-9 (DP)
4508/29/2014RESPONSE TO PETITION FOR REHEARINGAPPELLANT, BY COUNSEL, FILED RESPONSE TO PETITION FOR REHEARING. [REINSERTED STEP-PAB-4/2/15]
4609/05/2014RESPONSE TO PETITION FOR REHEARINGAPPELLEES, BY COUNSEL, FILED RESPONSE TO APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR MODIFICATION OR EXTENSION. TIMELY FILED (SENT BY REGISTERED MAIL ON 9/3/14). PURSUANT TO CR 76.40(2). [REINSERTED STEP-PAB-4/2/15]
4709/09/2014PET. FOR REHEARING-ASSIGNED/SENT OUTCOMBS CAPERTON AND DIXON [REINSERTED STEP-PAB-4/2/15]
4902/06/2015ORDER DENYING PETITION FOR REHEARINGDIXON (PJ), CAPERTON AND COMBS ORDER - DENYING APPELLEE'S PETITION FOR REHEARING. [REINSERTED STEP-PAB-4/2/15]
5002/06/2015ORDER GRANTING PETITION FOR REHEARINGDIXON (PJ), CAPERTON AND COMBS ORDER - GRANTING APPELLANT'S PETITION FOR REHEARING, ON BEHALF OF MOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY. THE OPINION RENDERED ON AUGUST 1, 2014, IS HEREBY WITHDRAWN, AND THE ATTACHED OPINION IS SUBSTITUTED IN ITS ENTIRETY FOR THE OPINION PREVIOUSLY RENDERED.
5102/06/2015OPINION - REVERSING & REMANDINGOPINION REVERSING AND REMANDING DIXON CAPERTON (CONCURS) AND COMBS (CONCURS IN RESULT ONLY) NOT TO BE PUBLISHED 22 PAGES
5202/23/2015PETITION FOR REHEARINGPETITION FOR MODIFICATION FILED BY RAY JONES. PAID $150.00 CHECK #1182 **PETITION WITHDRAWN A PER COURT ORDER 05/14/15
5302/24/2015PETITION FOR REHEARINGPETITION FOR MODIFICATION FILED BY DAVID C. JONES. PAID $150.00 CHECK #7131
5403/25/2015PET. FOR REHEARING-ASSIGNED/SENT OUTCOMBS (PJ) LAMBERT, J. AND DIXON [REINSERTED STEP-PAB-4/2/15]
5503/25/2015PET. FOR REHEARING-ASSIGNED/SENT OUTCOMBS (PJ) LAMBERT, J. AND DIXON [REINSERTED STEP-PAB-4/2/15]
5704/15/2015ORDER ON COURT'S OWN MOTIONNOTICE OF SUBSTITUTION -THE COURT HAS FOUND IT NECESSARY TO ASSIGN THIS APPEAL TO A DIFFERENT THREE-JUDGE PANEL THAN THE ONE ORIGINALLY ASSIGNED. THE FOLLOWING PANEL SHALL HEAR THE APPEAL: JUDGE SARA COMBS, PRESIDING JUDGE, JUDGE DONNA DIXON AND JUDGE JAMES LAMBERT.
5804/15/2015SUBSTANTIVE MOTIONAGREED ORDER DISMISSING TREATED AS PARTIES' JOINT MOTION TO WITHDRAW PETITION FOR REHEARING, FILED BY HON. KEVIN KEENE AND HON. DAVID JONES ###D/29 (SCANNED TO W.D.)
5904/29/2015MOTIONS SCHEDULED FOR FOLLOWING STEPS. 
6005/11/2015RECORD RETURNED FROM JUDGE'S CHAMBERS.JUDGE DIXON RETURNED 1 BROWN CASE WALLET AND 4 BOXES RECORD ON SHELF #'S 20 AND 21, ON 5/8/L15.
6105/14/2015ORDER GRANTING SUBSTANTIVE MOTIONORDER - GRANTING AGREED ORDER DISMISSING TREATED AS PARTIES' JOINT MOTION TO WITHDRAW PETITIONS FOR REHEARING.
6208/06/2015FINALITYRETURNED 13 VOLUMES RECORD, 11 CD'S, 27 DEPOSITIONS, 1 BINDER DEPOSITION EXHIBITS, 1 EXHIBIT (PICTURE), 1 DEPOSITION EXHIBIT, 1 ANSWER TO INTERROGATORIES, 1 ENVELOPE MISC., 1 SEALED ENVELOPE, 6 ENVELOPES EXHIBITS, 7 MEMORANDUMS/REPLIES, 9 MOTIONS/REPLIES, 3 INTERROGATORIES, 1 PETITION WRIT OF MANDAMUS, 1 PRETRIAL COMPLIANCE TO THE PIKE CIRCUIT COURT BY UPS. UPS TRACKING # 1Z E40 237 03 4746 4556, 4614 9363, 4726 4174, 4780 8989 8/10/15- RECEIVED COPY OF RECEIPT FROM THE PIKE CIRCUIT COURT DATED 8/7/15.
 

Litigant Information   Case Information   StepSheet Attorneys Circuit Appeals
 
DescriptionPrimary(Y/N)NameSeq #
AppellantYMOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY 1
AppelleeYGYPSIETHACKER 2
AppelleeNMANN, SUTTON & MCGEE, LTD. 3
 

Attorney Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Circuit Appeals
 
Attorney(s)Attorney's AddressParty NameParty Type
GUY R. COLSON FOWLER, MEASLE & BELL, LLP, 300 WEST VINE STREET, SUITE 600, LEXINGTON, KY 40507-1660 MANN, SUTTON & MCGEE, LTD. Appellee
WILLIAM HICKMAN IIIJONES & HICKMAN, P.S.C., P O DRAWER 3850, PIKEVILLE, KY 41502 GYPSIETHACKER Appellee
GARY C. JOHNSON GARY C. JOHNSON, P.S.C., 570 EAST MAIN ST., LEXINGTON, KY 40588-1717 GYPSIETHACKER Appellee
JIM G. VANOVER VANOVER, HALL & BARTLEY, PSC, 152 3RD STREET, PIKEVILLE, KY 41501 GYPSIETHACKER Appellee
DAVID CLARENCE JONES KRIZ JENKINS PREWITT & JONES, P.S.C., PNC BANK PLAZA, 200 WEST VINE STREET, SUITE 710, LEXINGTON, KY 40507-1620 MOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY Appellant
RAY STANLEY JONES IIJONES & HICKMAN, P.S.C., P.O. BOX 3850, PIKEVILLE, KY 41502 GYPSIETHACKER Appellee
RHONDA JENNINGS BLACKBURN GARY C. JOHNSON, PSC, 110 CAROLINE AVENUE, P.O. BOX 231, PIKEVILLE, KY 41502 GYPSIETHACKER Appellee
CHRISTOPHER S TURNERKRIZ, JENKINS, PREWITT & JONES PSC, BB&T WEST VINE STREET, 200 W VINE ST, SUITE 710, LEXINGTON, KY 40507-1620 MOTORISTS MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY Appellant
 

Circuit Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Appeals
 
CountyCase #Judgement DateJudge Name
PIKE(098)(Case #: 09-CI-01040 ) (Court:1) (Division:Circuit Court )12/21/2012HON COLEMAN, EDDY
 

Associated Appeals Information   Case Information   StepSheet Litigants Attorneys Circuit
None